I have to say that I’m not in a position to assess the campaign worldwide, nothing remotely like that. I’m hoping that if I make a rather limited introduction, based around personal experience, mostly in Britain but also to some extent Europe-wide, then others can come in and fill the gaps and say what’s going on in other parts of the world. So that’s the situation that we’re in.
To make one or two general points: it was said in the previous session earlier today that the left, including ourselves, have come quite late to this whole issue, and that to some extent we’re catching up on these debates. I think that’s even truer when it comes to campaigning and mobilisations on climate change. We’re not yet located where we need to be in these campaigns. And the campaigns themselves, it has to be said, are a long way behind the objective necessity of the situation, a long way behind the urgency of the situation, and have yet really a long way to catch up to correspond to it.
So it seems to me that, although this item has come a bit earlier on the agenda and we haven’t really yet got on to campaigning, we really ought to come out of this seminar having made some advances on the campaigning side of things.
The Campaign against Climate Change
In Britain, the Campaign against Climate Change has been running for about eleven or twelve years, and has been organising demonstrations in London at the US Embassy for the last ten years. It also doubles up as an international campaign.
It’s interesting to trace its development over that period of time. I think you could almost say that each of its demonstrations has been bigger than the last, with the exception of 2007, which was smaller, but it was torrential rain for the whole day, so it wasn’t a very good indication. It’s generally been bigger each year. It built up to a demonstration in 2006 of 25,000, which is the biggest of the London demonstrations. It also expanded internationally, to I think 22 or 23 countries that simultaneously held demonstrations on climate change at the beginning of December. So it’s an important contribution that that campaign has made.
The campaign is around a single issue: an effective international treaty on climate change. That’s what it’s about. It discusses all kinds of other things, but its actual demands are around an international treaty on CO2 reduction. And it does it from the standpoint that there’s only one atmosphere, so it’s the ultimate international issue, in a sense, and can’t ultimately be dealt with in any one country. Therefore an international treaty is absolutely key; that’s the way the campaign sees it. There is a logic in that, in having a single issue that you can campaign on internationally.
It’s not an easy campaign to work in. It has annual conferences, which deal with a whole range of issues, with a whole range of workshops and speakers from all over the world, and it takes policy decisions and so on. However, while it wouldn’t be true to say that it’s undemocratic, nevertheless it lacks something in terms of decision-making processes. You never quite know where the decisions are coming from and who’s taking them, which makes it quite difficult to work in.
But it is the main campaign. There are other, broader campaigns. We’ve had a campaign in Britain called the Big Ask, which has embraced a lot of the big NGOs, like Greenpeace, War on Want and Friends of the Earth. It’s not a campaigning campaign in the same way, of mobilising people on the streets, but in terms of consciousness-raising it makes quite a big contribution, and organises concerts and all that kind of thing.
The climate camps
The other part of the campaign in Britain has been the direct-action campaign, which started in 2006 around power stations, around the big Drax power station, and continued this year with a camp at Heathrow Airport. This was, it has to be said, an extremely effective campaign in terms of the publicity it achieved, and it’s a very interesting part of the campaign as well.
Of course, it was hitting a very, very big target: the plans for a third runway at Heathrow. It’s not really a third runway; it’s almost like another airport next to Heathrow, with a sixth terminal. It would raise the capacity of Heathrow from half a million flights a year at the present time to 720,000 flights, a capacity of 100 million passengers. That is what it would make Heathrow. To build it they have to obliterate a village, and half of another village, which are currently close to Heathrow. So it was a very big target.
There were only about 700 actually involved in the climate camp, nearly all young people, because it’s very much a young person’s thing. I was there, but it’s very much a young person’s thing. And it achieved wall-to-wall publicity for the whole seven days that it existed: continuous publicity, debates in all parts of the media, much more publicity than demonstrations and things have achieved. It’s partly because the media and the authorities never know what’s going to happen next, because it’s an illegal camp. It goes and occupies a piece of land, sets up a whole tented village, and runs it on the basis of sustainable living.
It’s a very interesting thing. The food is all vegetarian, because it wouldn’t really make sense to have a climate camp chomping away on hamburgers and steaks. All the power used on the camp is generated on the camp; all the toilets are compost toilets; so it’s a totally sustainable space. It’s very highly organised, with a visitor system and so on, and it has continuous workshops every day on a wide range of subjects: from direct action — what’s the most effective thing to glue yourself to, or ought we to climb over the fence and sit on the runway or not — to every aspect of the whole ecological issue you can think of. Workshops on ecology in China, ecology in Latin America, the debates around contraction and convergence: continuous workshops, and then going off and doing direct action, interspersed between them.
So it’s a very effective form of action, although really only a minority one: you’ve got to be quite young and active, and prepared to put yourself in a certain amount of danger, to do it. But it’s important, and it’s effective, and it’s very important that the wider left gets involved in that kind of thing.
Taking the issue into the unions
One of the things we’ve tried to do in the Campaign against Climate Change has been to turn the issue towards the trade unions. It’s not an easy issue to take into the unions, because unions tend to respond according to where they’re located. Unions in the manufacturing industry are difficult to address, because the whole issue of productivism comes up, and it raises the question of what your attitude actually is towards production. Are we actually concerned with what is produced, or only with the conditions under which it’s produced? It’s a very, very big debate in the unions.
When I was an active trade unionist, we never ever addressed what was being produced: whether it was damaging to the environment or not. And this was cars; that wasn’t addressed at all. The only things we addressed at that time were whether the wages were high enough and whether the working conditions were adequate. If the wages were high enough and the working conditions adequate, [?full stop?], then what we were producing didn’t matter. That was the way we looked at it at the time.
Those days are now gone. We can no longer be unconcerned about what is produced and its effects on the environment. And so this raises the whole issue of alternative production, and the debates in the unions over alternative production, which have come up in the past in different ways: proposing that different things are produced from the ones produced at present. It’s very difficult to raise in the unions.
The trade-union conference
This conference was highly successful. It didn’t really manage to raise those things, but it attracted 300 delegates from trade unions, and it had a very good discussion on the whole issue of the involvement of trade unions around these issues. It was clear from there that there are changes taking place in the unions. A lot of unions now, in Britain anyway, have environmental reps who deal with the ecological issues in the workplace; that is an increasing trend. And of course some unions are quite happy to engage the issue fully, because there’s no downside for them. But it’s very difficult again with the unions at places like airports. They’re often in favour of expansion, because there are another 10,000 jobs, or 7,000 jobs, involved in an additional runway. So it’s a very difficult thing, but it’s very important to engage with these issues.
So it was a successful conference, and it set up an ongoing campaign in the unions to raise these issues. There was a very impressive intervention by the leader of the Fire Brigades Union, because of the implications for the fire and rescue service: as extreme weather events become more frequent, the demands on the emergency services are becoming more extreme, more dangerous and more difficult. In Britain that means that rather than just putting out fires, they now have to deal with floods on a much more frequent basis. So that was an interesting debate.
The left and the campaign
I think it’s very important that we’re able to insert ourselves into these kinds of campaigns. In Britain, the left has been late, and sections of the left respond differently to this. The SWP, for example, are very strongly in the climate change campaign. However, it’s really a number of specialists within the SWP who have a particular interest; it’s not really the SWP as such which is fully behind the campaign. There’s a big discrepancy between its priorities as a national organisation and what some of its members do in the campaign. The Socialist Party, the CWI, for example, have really no involvement in it at all. They’re not really active in it, and it doesn’t really reflect in their press.
But it is something which certainly is not going to go away. So I think getting it right, in terms of involvement in these campaigns and in the debates around them, is extremely important.
Now, I know that’s a very particular point of view, from Britain and a little bit from Europe, and this presents itself differently in Latin America and in different parts of the world. But that’s the experience that we have had in terms of campaigning.


