The Drift, part 5.
The Alliance for Workers’ Liberty does something most of the left does not. It keeps its old arguments in print. Its pamphlet Arabs, Jews and Socialism reprints the 1985 debate in which Socialist Organiser, the paper the AWL grew from, gave up the democratic secular state in Palestine and adopted two states. It prints the losing side as well as the winning one. It even prints the editorial from 1973 that its founder later disowned.
That is to the AWL’s credit, and it makes this part of the series easy to write honestly. Part 4 asked why an organisation that sends volunteers to the olive harvest argues against the boycott at home. The answer starts in 1985, and the AWL has published the evidence itself.
I was a member of Socialist Organiser at the time, and a letter of mine is in the pamphlet. I come to that in section 6, and say plainly where I stood.
1. The secular state was the paper’s position, under its editor’s name
In October 1973 Workers’ Fight, the paper of Sean Matgamna’s group, carried an editorial on the October war. “A decisive and crushing defeat for Israel will be good news for revolutionary workers,” it said. Israel “has no right to exist.” But it was just as clear that the defeat of Israel “is not at all the demand to expel or drive out her population.” The only solution was “a secular democratic state” with a full right of return for the Palestinians and full equality with the Jews.
Ten years later the line was the same. In April 1983 Matgamna answered Gerry Healy’s smear that Socialist Organiser was a “Zionist connection” by setting out what the paper stood for. It opposed Zionism, and it advocated a secular democratic state in Palestine in which Jews and Arabs could live as equals.
The 1985 reprints add a detail. When the debate opened, the paper said its editor had held “a minority point of view” for about seven years. Minutes of a 1980 Workers’ Action editorial board, also reprinted, show him calling the secular state slogan one that “has no grip on reality.” So the 1983 reply set out the majority’s position, not his own. That is how an editor of a democratic paper should behave, and nobody should hold it against him. But it means that from 1985 the question was not whether Matgamna would change his mind. It was whether the members would come round to his.
2. The debate was real, and it was settled by the editorial board
It was a real debate. From June 1985 the paper ran a series of short pieces for and against. Bruce Robinson argued for a single state with collective rights for both nations. Robert Fine, who backed the break with “third world nationalism”, still doubted that two states would help the Jews and Arabs who wanted to escape a Jewish state’s religious and military grip. Tony Greenstein of the Labour Movement Campaign for Palestine argued that a West Bank state would be “an Israeli Bantustan”. A representative of Mapam, the Israeli socialist Zionist party, wrote in to welcome the new turn. The paper printed them all.
The members did not rush. The Socialist Organiser AGM on 22-23 June 1985 “felt that we weren’t yet ready to take a decision”, and resolved to keep discussing. Eleven weeks later, on Sunday 8 September, the decision was taken for them at a meeting of the National Editorial Board (a echo of the group’s change of line on the class nature of the Eastern bloc countries). A motion for two states was carried against one calling for a single democratic state. The paper’s report called the secular state “an unattainable fantasy” and “at best” a “consoling fantasy”.
A board can take decisions, and this one had a long discussion behind it. But it is worth knowing that the turn which shaped the next forty years of the AWL’s Palestine work was not voted on by the members who had just said they were not ready.
3. The case for two states, read fairly
The two-states side made three serious arguments, and they deserve a fair hearing.
Matgamna’s was the bluntest. There were, he wrote, “only two alternatives”: drive out the Jews, or create two states. The first “has no place in our programme”. So two states it had to be.
Martin Thomas made the strongest case. The secular state, he argued, told the Palestinians either to wait for the Arab states to conquer Israel or to wait for the Israeli Jews to become internationalists. Socialists should instead offer the Palestinians aims “which they can win without having to rely on dubious external saviours.” A Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza was such an aim. They could, “in principle”, force it from Israel.
Clive Bradley added a third. Recognising Israel’s national rights meant one thing only: opposing its conquest from outside. It did not mean accepting “that an inherently racist, discriminatory state is unchangeable.” We are against conquering the Jews, he wrote. “We are not against transforming the Israeli state from within.”
Some of this was right and still is. Socialists are not for the conquest of a people. The Israeli Jews are a nation, and a programme that pretends otherwise will never win a single Jewish worker. Thomas’s test, that the oppressed should be offered aims they can win, is a good test for any programme. The question is whether two states passed it.
4. Forty years have tested the forecast
In August 1985 Greenstein put the settlers in the West Bank at over 30,000, the figure most people quoted then. The true count was already nearer 45,000, not including East Jerusalem. Today there are over 500,000 in the West Bank, and some 700,000 counting East Jerusalem. The PLO accepted two states in 1988 and recognised Israel at Oslo in 1993. It did what Thomas hoped the Palestinians would do. It got a divided territory, a wall, a blockade of Gaza, and, since 2023, mass killing on a scale that the 1985 debaters on both sides would not have believed.
The two states position did not cause any of that. But its central forecast was that this was the realistic aim, the one the Palestinians could win without external saviours. That forecast failed. The Israeli state refused the compromise even when the Palestinian leadership accepted it.
Robinson saw the danger in 1985. A West Bank and Gaza state, he wrote, “would either have no room for independent action and be subject to Israeli domination” or would soon clash with Israeli “national interests”. Greenstein, for all the heat of his articles, saw it too.
Today the AWL’s delegation in the West Bank calls for a Palestinian state “with the abolition of all settlements” and a movement “with international backing”. That is now a demand for the removal of hundreds of thousands of settlers and the army that guards them. Thomas once said the secular state was like Marx’s “labour money”: possible only when nobody would want it any more. Forty years on, two states with no settlements looks the same way.
5. The third option was printed in the paper, and dropped
The board chose between two formulas. There was a third, and Socialist Organiser printed it.
In August 1985 the paper carried “A socialist union of the Middle East” by Moshé Machover and Jabra Nicola, written in 1969 and adopted by Matzpen, the Israeli Socialist Organisation. It rejected both a secular state confined to Palestine and a Palestinian mini-state. Zionism, it argued, could not be beaten “without overthrowing imperialist domination throughout the region”, and a formula for Palestine alone, “despite its revolutionary appearance”, was reformist. The Israeli Jews were a national community, and had to be won from Zionism “to a joint struggle with the revolutionary forces in the Arab world”. In a liberated region they would have the right to self-determination. And “recognition of the rights to self determination does not mean encouragement to separation,” it said. Instead it provides “the correct basis for integration without compulsion or repression.”
Machover spoke at the summer school that month. As the paper reported, he proposed two slogans: a socialist Arab federation, with self-determination for non-Arab minorities such as the Hebrew nation; and immediately, self-determination for the Palestinians where they were a majority. Matgamna “agreed with the gist”, but warned against putting off answers until after the revolution. Workers had to be united before the revolution, so the programme needed proposals that could unite them now.
That is a fair point. But it cuts both ways. The proposal the board chose to unite Jewish and Arab workers in 1985 was a border. The socialist federation of the Middle East survived in the 1985 resolution, but as a subordinate clause (”our programme is a socialist federation of the Middle East”). The same board said that “the socialist revolution itself is much nearer” than a common secular state. If it was nearer, it belonged at the head of the answer. Instead it went to the back. By 2024 the AWL called it its “long-range programme”, with two states as the immediate one. The last time we have found it calling for the federation in its own name was in February 2025. In the delegation’s posts from the West Bank in October 2026 it does not appear at all.
Robinson had put the principle in Lenin’s words, from a polemic against Rosa Luxemburg. The proletariat demands “as a matter of principle, that there should be no privileges, however slight.” Part 2 of this series traced how the AWL turned consistent democracy into a description of what exists. This is where that started. Robinson’s conclusion was blunt. “No solution is possible while the Israeli working class enjoys privileges at the expense of the Palestinians.”
6. Where I stood in 1987
I should say where I was in this. I joined Socialist Organiser after the turn and held the two states position, in a form you could call two states after the revolution. By the winter of 1986-87 the argument had moved on from borders to a word. Matgamna, writing as Mick Ackersley, proposed that “Zionism” now logically meant support for Israel’s right to exist, so that anyone who supported that right was a Zionist of a kind. Bradley and others objected. A letter in the paper accused Matgamna of condoning racist oppression.
My letter, “A socialist federation”, ran in Socialist Organiser 302 on 12 February 1987. The AWL reprints it on page 69 of the pamphlet. I defended Matgamna against the charge of condoning racism, and then disagreed with him. We took two states, I wrote, not out of support for Israeli chauvinism but because we recognised the national rights of both peoples. That should not lead us to support the state of Israel “in the way John O’Mahony seems to.” Then:
What we want is class unity for a socialist federation of the Middle East. Recognising those national rights lays a basis for building that unity.
I said our support for Israel’s existence rested “on our opposition to that blood-bath”, meaning a military conquest, and not on any view that Israel’s existence was “the best possible state of affairs in the Middle East.”
I quote it because it shows that the two states position in Socialist Organiser was never one thing. For some of us it was a step towards a socialist federation, held for fear of a war of conquest. For the leadership it was becoming a defence of Israel’s existence against an “anti-Zionist” left it saw as the main danger. In the pamphlet my letter is followed by a Matgamna piece from the same months, which the paper did not print at the time. It names the main problem as “Judaeophobic ‘anti-Zionism’” on the left. Forty years later, that is the line that runs through the AWL’s work on Palestine. It is the reason the AWL argues against the boycott.
7. Why I now support a democratic secular state
My letter gave two reasons for two states. The first was the national rights of both peoples. The second was opposition to a blood-bath. Both still matter to me. They now point the other way.
The blood-bath of my letter was the conquest of Israel. The blood-bath that has come is Israel’s war on Gaza, carried out by the state whose existence we defended as the lesser danger. A position built on preventing slaughter has to look at who is doing the slaughtering.
National rights do not need a border. Machover’s point in 1969, printed in our own paper in 1985, was that self-determination is the basis for living together without compulsion, not a demand for separation. Robinson proposed collective rights for both nations, in language, religion, education and local government, inside one state. The Fourth International’s 2025 World Congress calls for a free, democratic and secular Palestine where the refugees can return and everyone lives as equals. That is a programme that recognises the Hebrew nation and ends its privilege. Equal citizenship takes nobody’s nationhood away.
And two states has failed Thomas’s own test. It is no longer an aim the Palestinians can win without outside help. Every route to it now runs through the removal of the settlements, which means the defeat of Zionism. So does the democratic state. The difference is that the democratic state says so, and tells Jewish workers what they gain: an end to permanent war, and a place in a democratic Palestine and a socialist Middle East. That is still what I wanted in 1987. I just no longer think a border is the way to it.
8. What the AWL could take from its own pamphlet
The AWL does not have to agree with me to learn from its own record. It could:
reopen the question in Solidarity as Socialist Organiser did in 1985, printing Palestinian socialists, the BDS unions and the one-state left alongside its own view;
put the socialist federation of the Middle East back at the head of its Palestine programme, where Matzpen put it, rather than in a subordinate clause;
stop treating the right of return as a programme of conquest, as its own paper did not in 1973 or 1982;
and, as Part 4 argued, back the boycott, divestment and sanctions that the Palestinian unions have asked for.
In 1985 the paper ended its report of the turn with a promise: “The discussion will continue.” The AWL printed that sentence again in 2019. It should keep the promise.


