Socialism by Enabling Act: Militant and the state
At the Labour Party Young Socialists’ summer camp in 1987, when I was a member of Socialist Organiser, I put a question to Ted Grant. I had been reading Lenin’s The State and Revolution, and I asked him why Militant never said what Lenin said: that the working class cannot simply take hold of the existing state machine, and has to break it. Grant’s answer was that talking about revolution in that way was ultra-left. Marxists should talk about defending a socialist government against capitalist counter-revolution, because to talk of anything else would lead to blood on the streets.
This series is about that answer. Most of the rest of the British revolutionary left had a name for the politics behind it: centrism. The word was used of Militant by the Socialist Labour League, the Workers Socialist League, the International Marxist Group, the Socialist League and its successors, Socialist Organiser and Workers Power, and from outside the Fourth International tradition by the Socialist Workers Party. It was used carelessly as often as carefully. The aim is to say which parts of Militant’s approach the word fits, using what those critics wrote at the time. This first part deals with the state. Part 2 deals with the programme Militant put to the labour movement, and with Ireland, Vietnam, the Falklands and the oppressed. Part 3 takes the miners’ strike of 1984–85. Part 4 follows the story through Militant Labour, the Socialist Party and the Scottish Socialist Party, to see what changed when Militant left the Labour Party and what did not.
A disclosure first. I was a member of Socialist Organiser at the time of that exchange, and later of the International Socialist Group, the British section of the Fourth International. Both organisations’ papers are quoted in this series: Socialist Organiser for the 1980s, and the ISG’s Socialist Outlook for the 1990s and early 2000s. Their writers were Militant’s rivals in the LPYS and the Labour Party, and in the case of the Socialist Alliance its opponents. Read them with that in mind.
What the word means
Trotsky used “centrism” for currents that sit between reform and revolution: revolutionary in their programme on paper, reformist in what that programme asks of the working class now, and held together by formulas vague enough to cover the gap. In “Centrism and the Fourth International“ (1934) he added a feature that matters for Militant: centrism combines opportunism towards the reformist leaders with sectarianism towards the revolutionaries to its left.
Judith Arkwright found exactly that combination in Militant in the IMG’s journal International in 1983, reviewing Peter Taaffe’s pamphlet What We Stand For while Militant’s editorial board was being expelled from the Labour Party. Her review, “Why Militant is the Target“, defended Militant against the witch-hunt. But what the pamphlet illustrated, she wrote, was that “the politics of the tendency leads it to a stance which is simultaneously sectarian and opportunist”.
Phil Hearse put it more bluntly in the same weeks. Writing as Paul Lawson in International Viewpoint on Labour’s defeat in the Bermondsey by-election (no. 26, 21 March 1983), he added a footnote for readers outside Britain:
“Militant is in fact a centrist political tendency originating in a split from the Fourth International in 1965. Its most characteristic feature is its extreme propagandism, notably its reduction of all political problems to the ‘nationalisation of the 200 leading monopolies’.”
Those two descriptions, “sectarian and opportunist” and “extreme propagandism”, are the threads of what follows.
A socialist programme through Parliament
Militant’s central slogan, when Labour was out of office, was “Labour to power on a socialist programme”. Its programme was the nationalisation of the top 200 monopolies, later 250, by an Enabling Act passed in Parliament, “with compensation on the basis of proven need”.
The Militant International Review set out the perspective in June 1974. Bob McKee’s “Britain: a minority Labour government“ (MIR no. 9) foresaw a left Labour government “pledged to carry out a full programme of socialism”:
“An Enabling Act to take over the major monopolies and banks, would lay the basis for a plan of production to meet the minimum needs of working people and begin to lay the basis of a socialist society. The success of such a policy would then depend on the development of a Marxist leadership capable of mobilising and uniting the whole working class into action, to defend the programme of socialism. Such unity in action would sweep away any attempt at reaction that is now being prepared by the ruling class.”
That is Grant’s answer to me, written down thirteen years earlier. Mass action enters the picture only after Parliament has acted, and only to defend what Parliament has done. The ruling class is the side that will resort to force, and the working class prevails by its numbers, its unity and its leadership. There is no moment at which the working class itself has to take power, break up the armed forces of the old state and put its own organs in their place.
Militant would say the same thing in its own paper whenever it was asked. In 1977 the Labour right demanded to know whether Militant’s aims could be achieved democratically. The LPYS representative on Labour’s National Executive, Nick Bradley, replied in the Guardian that the socialist transformation in Britain would come “democratically” and “peacefully”, and Militant backed him: “To her demand for unequivocal answers from us on whether our socialist objectives can be achieved democratically, we reply, Yes!” The IMG quoted the exchange in its pamphlet The Politics of Militant (1977), along with Militant‘s statement of 4 February 1977 that its aims could be achieved democratically only if Labour’s leaders were “ready to introduce an Enabling Act (as proposed in 1937 by Clement Attlee), abolishing the House of Lords and the Monarch and taking emergency powers to nationalise the monopolies”. The pamphlet’s verdict:
“Demands and slogans like ‘Labour to Power on a Socialist Programme’, Militant’s central slogan when Labour is out of office, give the impression that Labour can carry out a socialist programme through parliament on behalf of the working class, thus strengthening illusions in parliamentary democracy and by-passing the whole question of the State.”
Taaffe’s What We Stand For (1981) put the condition in a single sentence, quoted by Arkwright: “a peaceful transformation of society is possible in Britain, but only on the condition that the full power of the labour movement is boldly used”. The condition is real, and Militant always stated it. But it is a condition on the parliamentary road, not an alternative to it. In 1978 Hearse, in the IMG’s On Trotskyism and the Fourth International, drew the line against “currents of the ‘Militant’ variety, who with their theory of an ‘enabling act’ put the revolutionary character of the transition into question.”
The same logic ran through Militant’s view of the state’s armed bodies. At the 1981 LPYS summer camp, just after the riots in Brixton, Toxteth and Moss Side, Jon Lansman reported in Socialist Organiser (”Militant preaches peace with the police“, no. 48, 13 August 1981) that the week’s debate centred on Militant’s position that the police and army were “workers in uniform”, who should be unionised and brought into the TUC. Lansman agreed that socialists should support soldiers’ and police officers’ democratic rights, including the right to form unions. His objection was to what Militant expected from them: such rights “do not turn cops into workers”, and “Militant dreams about a future democratic, unionised benevolent police force.”
Militant’s own case
Militant had a reply, and it deserves a hearing.
It never claimed that the ruling class would accept a socialist government quietly. McKee’s 1974 article is about the ruling class preparing for “confrontation to smash the organised working class movement”, and Militant drew the lessons of Chile in 1973 at length. Its argument was about how to talk to British workers. A working class with a century of parliamentary democracy behind it would not be won by talk of insurrection. It would be won by a programme it could recognise, carried by its own party, and it would learn the rest in defending that programme against the inevitable resistance. When Dave Packer reviewed the debate in Scotland for Socialist Outlook in 1998, he noted that Militant’s “emphasis on parliamentary ‘Enabling Acts’” had always “been defended as merely a pedagogic device”.
Militant could also point out, fairly, that most of its critics were tiny and that it was not. It led the LPYS from 1970, grew to something like 8,000 members, ran Liverpool City Council and led the most successful mass campaign of the Thatcher years, against the poll tax.
The best version of Militant’s case I have heard came recently, in a long conversation with an American comrade. He spent many years as a leader of Labor Militant, the CWI’s group in the United States, and was expelled from it in a faction fight in 1996. He still thinks the Enabling Act was the right way to put things, and his reasons deserve setting out.
His first argument is about Militant’s position inside the Labour Party. Labour’s rules had always barred organised groups, even if they were rarely enforced. A tendency that called openly for revolution would have given the party machine its grounds for expulsion. So Militant spoke of an Enabling Act backed by the power of the working class in the streets, and kept the rest for its own discussions. In Labor Militant, he says, nobody doubted that the working class could not take power through the existing capitalist state. What that meant concretely in a given country was a separate question. The rule, as he puts it, is that you never say anything you do not believe, but you need not say everything you do. He grants that some members in Britain never fully understood the difference.
His second argument is about the word itself. As he reads Trotsky, centrism belongs to revolutionary and pre-revolutionary periods. In those periods, currents like Andreu Nin’s POUM in Spain take up revolutionary language without the strategy to match it, and end up as reformists in practice. Militant was doing nothing of the kind. It was not adapting to a revolutionary upsurge. It was adapting to a reformist leadership in a period of retreat. If it was anything, he says, it was opportunist, not centrist.
Both arguments need an answer.
The peaceful road for Britain, not for Chile
The first assumes that Militant’s public formula covered a different position held in private. My experience was the opposite. Grant’s answer to me came neither from a platform nor in the press. He gave it in a little marquee at a Militant-organised summer camp, to a teenage Young Socialist, with nobody else to hear it, and it was the same answer the paper gave. A few hundred of Militant’s members may have understood the Enabling Act as a formula. For most of its eight thousand, it was simply how socialism would come, because that is what they were taught. And other Trotskyists worked inside Labour for years without it. They raised united-front demands in the party and kept their propaganda for their own meetings, but they did not build a parliamentary road to socialism into their programme.
Militant’s own pages show where the line ran. A member who joined in the 1970s and left in 1985 says he argued inside the organisation that the Enabling Act could be misread, and points to what Militant wrote about real revolutions: Spain, Hungary, France in 1968, Chile. On Chile he is right. In January 1974 the Militant International Review gave ten thousand words to Roger Silverman’s “Counter-revolution in Chile” (no. 8). It quoted Marx: the task of the revolution is no longer “to transfer the bureaucratic-military machine from one hand to another, but to smash it, and this is essential for every real people’s revolution”. It reprinted Militant’s own warning of October 1971: “The sympathy of the soldiers will be of no avail unless the hold of the officer caste is shattered. That is impossible unless the army is faced with a powerful movement of the armed people. While Allende and the CP are busy lulling the masses with beautiful pictures of ‘peaceful parliamentary change’, the ruling class is systematically preparing for a counter-stroke.” And it drew the lesson for Britain, “the England of South America”: let a Labour government threaten the economic base of the Tories and Fleet Street, and “there will be no shortage of Generals who will ‘in good faith’” intervene. “The British Labour Movement, in preparing to contend with the upheavals of the next few years, will ignore the lessons of Chile at their peril.”
The next issue carried McKee’s article on Britain. It saw the same danger, down to the army’s exercises with the police at Heathrow. Its answer was the Enabling Act and “unity in action”. It said nothing about a militia, an appeal to the troops or the state machine. Yet the same issue’s article on Northern Ireland called for “a trade union defence force”, and said that Militant supporters “have always held that a consistent class appeal should be made to the troops in the North”. Militant applied the lessons of Chile to Chile and to Ireland. It did not apply them to Britain, where its own article on Chile had warned they would be needed, and what it offered British workers instead was what it had condemned in Allende: beautiful pictures of peaceful parliamentary change.
Centrism doesn’t only appear in the revolutionary moment
The second argument is a fair reading of the cases Trotsky had in front of him in 1934, which were mostly currents moving left under the pressure of the crisis. But “Centrism and the Fourth International” describes a set of relationships, not a moment. The centrist “always remains in spiritual dependence upon right groupings”, and is induced “to keep silent about their opportunist faults”. It is “not a rare thing for the centrist to hide his own hybrid nature by calling out about the dangers of ‘sectarianism’”. Looking at the Communist International, the centrist sees “only the ‘ultra-left’ deviation”. Trotsky also insisted that “the oscillations of centrism to right and left proceed from its very nature”, and that some left-centrist groupings “halt in their development, and even go back upon it”. A tendency whose answer to Lenin was a warning about ultra-leftism fits that description whether or not there is a revolution under way.
The trouble with the pedagogic defence is what it does to the people being taught. A teaching method that cannot ever be dropped, so that naming the goal openly is ultra-left and will lead to blood on the streets, has stopped being a method. It has become the content. That is what Grant told me in 1987, and it is what Militant was still saying seven years later, after it had left the Labour Party, as Part 4 shows.
Next in this series
The theory of the state is one half of what made Militant centrist. Part 2 turns to the other: what Militant asked of the labour movement in the meantime, and what it would not ask. It starts with the charge the Workers Socialist League made in 1978, that Militant’s programme was a “left cover” for Callaghan and Healey, and goes on to Ireland, Vietnam and the South Atlantic in 1982, where a tendency that thought socialism could come peacefully decided that recalling a fleet would take an insurrection.



Sheila MacGregor's 'The history and politics of Militant' in International Socialism (Autumn 1986) is the SWP's take on the centrist/opportunist contention: see https://www.marxists.org/history/etol/newspape/isj2/1986/isj2-033/macgregor.html
Those who advocate a peaceful or parliamentary road to socialism aren’t simply putting forward an alternative route to a shared, common destination - socialism, they are arguing for a different outcome!