"An amendment from Jewish Greens conflated Zionism with Judaism and recast the question as one of safeguarding Jewish members. It fell too, after delegates heard that the motion has no bearing on party discipline."
This is very interesting. The reaction on the Bluesky Left has been total condemnation of the rejection of this amendment, calling it pure antisemitism and people saying they're quitting GPEW after this. The basis of this argument is that it calls upon Jewish GPEW members to break ties with their synagogues if they're pro-Zionist, which is impossible if you value Jewish community life. The equivalent would be Labour etc. demanding that Muslim members quit their mosques if they support "Islamism" or "terrorism".
No-one calls upon Jewish GPEW members to break ties with their synagogues. The defeated amendment said:
"This motion shall not be used to pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliation with Jewish community institutions, such as synagogues, community centres or denominational groups, that describe themselves as Zionist or used to discipline or sanction Jewish members for expressing views that would be non sanctionable if expressed by non Jewish members (such as support for a binational state, or two state solution).
We affirm our commitment to explicitly opposing Zionism in our internal and external communications going forward."
This was a redundant motion that only reduce the ability of Greens to criticise fundamentalist views that, while legal, have no place in the party's communications.
"An amendment from Jewish Greens conflated Zionism with Judaism and recast the question as one of safeguarding Jewish members. It fell too, after delegates heard that the motion has no bearing on party discipline."
This is very interesting. The reaction on the Bluesky Left has been total condemnation of the rejection of this amendment, calling it pure antisemitism and people saying they're quitting GPEW after this. The basis of this argument is that it calls upon Jewish GPEW members to break ties with their synagogues if they're pro-Zionist, which is impossible if you value Jewish community life. The equivalent would be Labour etc. demanding that Muslim members quit their mosques if they support "Islamism" or "terrorism".
No-one calls upon Jewish GPEW members to break ties with their synagogues. The defeated amendment said:
"This motion shall not be used to pressure, proscribe or discipline members based on affiliation with Jewish community institutions, such as synagogues, community centres or denominational groups, that describe themselves as Zionist or used to discipline or sanction Jewish members for expressing views that would be non sanctionable if expressed by non Jewish members (such as support for a binational state, or two state solution).
We affirm our commitment to explicitly opposing Zionism in our internal and external communications going forward."
This was a redundant motion that only reduce the ability of Greens to criticise fundamentalist views that, while legal, have no place in the party's communications.