The World Socialist Web Site says Alan Thornett “later embraced Pabloism”. Its obituary is a cut-down version of three older ICFI texts, and the cuts are where the case lies. Within a year of his expulsion, the organisation that expelled him was accused in print of going back to Pablo. The International he later joined heard him argue against its own majority’s softness towards the Kremlin.
Chris Marsden’s obituary, “Alan Thornett, 1937-2026: A militant won to Trotskyism who later embraced Pabloism“, is mostly not new. Its account of 1974 condenses three earlier texts:
the ICFI’s statement on “The Expulsion of Alan Thornett“ in How the WRP Betrayed Trotskyism;
Marsden’s own two-part “Alan Thornett’s denunciation of Trotskyism” of March 2008 (one, two);
the 2011 Historical and International Foundations of the Socialist Equality Party.
What the condensing leaves out is the case against it.
The older texts conceded what the obituary drops. The ICFI itself said in its 1986 statement that “physical violence was used against the Thornett group”, that Healy dealt with heretics “in the manner of … Henry the Eighth”, and that Thornett’s differences “had not reached the level at which a split could be justified in front of the working class”.
The “secret contact … in August 1974” rests on one source. That source is a 1980 statement by Robin Blick, whom the same ICFI text calls a renegade who became an “open anti-communist”. Even Blick puts the first meeting with Thornett in mid-September, not August.
The ICFI pinned the label of Pabloism on Thornett’s 1974 line, although his 1974 platform had itself called Pabloism a revision of Trotsky “from the opportunist right”. Within a year the Workers Socialist League returned it, with dates and quotations, against the Workers Revolutionary Party. It has never been answered.
The WSL’s founding documents asked for the political reply to Pablo that the International Committee had never made, and invited the United Secretariat to argue.
Inside the Fourth International, the tendency Thornett’s current helped to build fought its majority from the anti-Stalinist side, refusing “any support for glasnost dictated from above and restorationist perestroika”.
The one charge with real content, the broad parties of the 2000s, is an argument about tactics. Red Mole has its own criticisms to make there. It is not Pabloism, and the obituary’s praise of Healy’s “Make the left MPs fight” shows why.
An old text, cut down
Set the obituary beside its sources and the pattern is plain. “Lost the party several hundred members and its most important faction in basic industry” is the 1986 statement’s “cost the party several hundred members and wiped out its most important faction in basic industry”, nearly word for word. “His differences reflected the pressure of workers who had joined the party on an anti-Tory line” paraphrases the same statement. “Rather than politically combatting Thornett’s positions” condenses what Foundations calls Healy’s “mistake of moving to an organisational settlement before clarifying the political issues involved”. The obituary adds nothing on the forty years since 1986 except a list of organisations.
What the condensing removes is more interesting than what it keeps. In 1986 the International Committee wrote, of Healy’s conduct of the fight:
Healy ‘fought’ Thornett by mobilizing the Party apparatus against him, relying heavily on the middle-class academics and professionals to intimidate the minority and make the organizational case for expulsion. Physical violence was used against the Thornett group.
It wrote that “Healy dealt with heretics within the Party not in the manner of Trotsky but in that of Henry the Eighth”. It wrote that “the political differences raised by Thornett, to the extent that they had been developed in the autumn of 1974, had not reached the level at which a split could be justified in front of the working class”. It conceded that “Thornett’s platform had been partially built by the political line upon which the Party had been founded”, and that he represented “a large constituency within the WRP — for whose political confusion Healy and Banda were responsible”. And it gave the result: “the Trotskyist movement in Britain emerged from the struggle more disoriented than at any time in the previous 21 years.”
None of that is in the 2026 obituary. A reader of it would not learn that the ICFI’s own judgement on the 1974 expulsion was that it was violent and premature, and a political disaster for the expelling party.
The secret contact
The obituary’s gravest charge is that Thornett “responded in an unprincipled fashion, by making secret contact with representatives of the OCI in Britain in August 1974 to formulate a factional critique of the WRP, seeking to remove Healy as party leader.”
The source, in every ICFI text that gives one, is a statement by Robin Blick dated 4 November 1980, quoted at length in the 1986 statement. The ICFI describes Blick and Mark Jenkins, in the same chapter, as “two cowardly middle-class renegades … who were to eventually become open anti-communists”. Their account is accepted where it convicts Thornett, and its authors are damned where they appear in their own right.
The charge does not even follow its source. On Blick’s account, the first contact with the Western Region in “late August” was with Kate Blakeney, not Thornett. The first meeting with Thornett took place “in mid-September 1974, at an exit road on the M4 near Reading”. Blakeney told him the opposition “had no clear platform”. Foundations hardened that into “its documents were largely written by the OCI”, and the obituary moved the meeting into August.
Nor was anything hidden that needed hiding. The ICFI’s 1986 statement says the opposition’s documents were “reprinted in the WSL’s ‘The Battle for Trotskyism’ as solely their own”, and that the faction “lied to the Party leadership and the membership about its real origins”. The Battle for Trotskyism, published in February 1976, says otherwise. Its preface records that the documents carried Thornett’s signature but “were, however, the work of a small group of comrades”. Its account of the expulsions says of Blick’s group:
there is no doubt that a number of the questions Blick took up were correct and played an important role in the development of the positions contained in our first two documents. This does not in any way constitute or imply political agreement with the Bulletin group then or now.
The WSL’s account and Blick’s differ on how close the contact was, and there is a way to settle what mattered about it, which Macnair supplies below. The WSL says those who founded it “were in complete hostility to the Bulletin tendency throughout that period”. But the debt was acknowledged in print four years before Blick made his claim.
Whatever drafting help a car worker facing expulsion accepted, the question an obituary ought to ask is whether the arguments were right. The first of them, “Correct the Wrong Positions of the Party – Return to the Transitional Programme“, signed by Thornett and presented to the Central Committee on 12 October 1974, was about corporatism:
For some time now almost the entire leadership of the trade unions and the Labour Party have been designated as ‘corporatists’. I cannot accept this. The Corporate State is the incorporation of the working class into the state which necessarily involves the destruction of all independent organisations of the working class – in other words fascism.
“We must distinguish, as Trotsky did,” the document went on, “between a reformist, whose treachery opens the door to fascism, and fascism itself.” This was an argument about the united front and the Third Period. Thornett made the same argument in his own name in 1990, and the WRP’s subsequent history settled it.
The fairest verdict on Blick comes from a critic of Thornett, not a friend. Mike Macnair, writing in the Weekly Worker this week, has no sympathy for where Thornett ended up: he calls it “the Mandelite swamp”. On Blick he writes that the claim “is at best a half-truth”. He sees “no reason to suppose that Blick and his co-thinkers were lying outright” about holding discussions, “but it is clear that there were other influences on the Thornett group”. Macnair names the International Marxist Group’s Cowley cell, with its factory bulletin and its campaign to “open the books”. And he answers the puppet charge with what happened next: “the Thornett group did not go to the Lambertistes in 1975”. In Oxford, he adds, the WSL did not follow the OCI’s line on Israel-Palestine or its practice of building fronts under its own control. Instead, Macnair says, Thornett and his comrades “broke with Healy into an open engagement with the rest of the far left (including the ‘Pabloite’ IMG and the ‘state caps’)”. An agent of the OCI would have gone to the OCI. It did not, and its politics never converged with the OCI’s afterwards. So whatever Blick and Jenkins did at the typewriter (Blick claims whole sections, and the WSL acknowledged that some of the questions he raised were correct), they were the opposition’s typists and editors, not its political north star.
The left turn was a countdown
The obituary calls what Thornett opposed a “left turn”, taken because the WRP “expected that the return of a Labour government in 1974 would bring workers rapidly into conflict with it.” Thornett’s own account, in his obituary of Healy in Socialist Outlook in February 1990, is plainer:
By 1973 the politics of the WRP had reached crazy proportions. Healy was predicting imminent collapse of the capitalist system: so when the Heath Government imposed a three day week to conserve fuel during the oil crisis Healy announced we were on the verge of a military coup: Workers Press headlined ‘Countdown to Dictatorship’. Two months later we had a Labour government.
From Cowley we began a political challenge to this, and increasingly, the whole political framework of the WRP. Within weeks we were hounded and slandered as police agents. One comrade was beaten up by Healy personally. In 1974 we were expelled with 200 others.
He had said the same at the time. The first opposition document is careful about it:
During this period an imminent military coup was predicted by the party, and action taken organisationally in preparation. I think this prediction was wrong. It is true of course that a military or some other open dictatorship was and is the requirement of the ruling class. It is true that sections of the ruling class advocated this and that the troops at Heathrow were a preparation for the use of troops under civil war conditions. It seems to me wrong however to make a prognosis based simply on the subjective intentions of sections of the ruling class.
The ICFI has not given up the countdown. Its 1986 statement still defends the WRP’s “warnings of the dangers of a military coup in 1973-74”, which it says were “later confirmed in a detailed report, published in the capitalist press, on the crisis within the Tory cabinet”. Macnair grants that “there was, indeed, talk of a possible coup within the British state apparatus in 1974”, and the point should be granted. What he calls “this insanity” is what the WRP did with it: militants were told to “avoid confrontations in order to save money for the coming general strike”. “Against this insanity,” he writes, “Thornett and his co-thinkers went into opposition to Healy”. Readers can decide whether a cabinet crisis confirms a countdown to dictatorship. What the record shows is that the man the obituary calls a right-centrist was arguing about perspective, which Foundations now concedes was the WRP’s weak point: “a serious miscalculation regarding the tempo of development of the class struggle.”
The WSWS quotes the 1990 piece for “degenerate political monster” and “the Ceausescu of the British Trotskyist movement”. It does not quote these paragraphs. Nor does it quote the next ones, which record what Healy did with the party once the Cowley comrades had gone: “promising [Middle Eastern oil states] uncritical coverage for money”, supporting Gaddafi, and supporting “the execution of Iraqi CP members by the Iraqi regime”. That is what the obituary’s word “degeneration” covers. Thornett named it in print.
October 1975: the charge returned
The obituary’s title says Thornett “later embraced Pabloism”, with no date, no document and no position. The 2011 Foundations is more specific, and the specificity is revealing. It calls Thornett’s 1974 line “the resurgence of Pabloite revisionism”. It says this in the same chapter that admits the WRP itself had been founded “without any discussion in the International Committee, much less a thoroughgoing review of the political lessons of the struggle against Pabloism”, on “a watering down of the historically developed programme of Trotskyism”. The organisation that had watered down the programme expelled the man who objected to its corrections, and called him the Pabloite. The document it was expelling him for had already said what it thought of Pablo. Corporatism, it argued, was “a revision of the Marxist analysis of bureaucracy from the ultra-left”:
Pabloism, on the other hand, which says that bureaucracy can be forced under pressure from the masses to a revolutionary position, revises Trotsky from the opportunist right. Both of these theories are wrong.
The second document went further. “The defections to Pabloism and to opportunism that have taken place since the war cannot be separated from the sectarianism of the IC leadership and its abandonment of the Transitional Programme,” it said. “Does the leadership of the IC bear no responsibility for the liquidation of the International?”
Within a year the charge came back. In August 1975 Workers Press ran four articles by Stephen Johns, “Stalinism and the Liberation of Vietnam”, the last of them an attack on the WSL. Socialist Press replied on 15 October, the week of the League’s founding conference, under the headline “Vietnam: WRP on the Road Back to Pabloism”.
The case was this. Since the Vietnamese leadership had defeated imperialism, Johns reasoned, it could not be Stalinist. So he credited it with “a consistent revolutionary line” since 1941 and put every compromise down to “Stalinist training” or pressure from Moscow. And he defended the retreat of 1945–46 on the balance of forces inside Vietnam alone. That was the retreat in which the Stalinists welcomed British and French troops into Saigon and murdered the Vietnamese Trotskyists. The WSL quoted Johns:
in breaking empirically from the dictates of Stalinist peaceful coexistence the Vietnamese leadership were able to carry through the revolution
and set beside it Pablo on China in 1953:
Thus the Chinese CP has found itself and is now obliged to bend its policy in practice in a manner which approximates the fundamental positions of Trotskyism
“In two quite definite respects,” the WSL wrote, “Johns returns to tread in Pablo’s steps.” And it said why the International Committee was exposed to this:
In the 1953 split some of the present leaders of the WRP fought organisationally against Pablo’s liquidation of the Trotskyist cadres into Stalinism, but never took up the struggle to found a political reply to it. In the recent degeneration of the WRP leadership the wheel begins to come full circle.
Red Mole does not read 1953 as the WSL did. But on the ICFI’s own definition, adapting to Stalinism because it has won, this is an accusation of Pabloism against the WRP. It was made with dates and quotations, eleven years before the ICFI discovered the WRP’s betrayal of Trotskyism. In none of the four texts the obituary draws on has it been answered.
A political reply, not an organisational one
Four days later, on 19 October 1975, the WSL’s founding conference adopted “The Fourth International: Problems and Tasks”, printed in the first issues of Trotskyism Today (part one, part two). Its opening says what it is for:
intended to form the basis of a discussion within the world Trotskyist movement on the theoretical problems and tasks which need to be confronted in rebuilding the Fourth International.
Its judgement on the International Committee was the one the Vietnam article had reached:
It is important to understand that neither before, at, or after the split did the sections which came together to form the IC attempt any proper reply to Pablo’s positions or the resolutions of the Third World Congress. They were unable to go beyond an ‘orthodox’ reply to the central political conclusion which he drew - the need for entry (’deep entry’, ‘entry sui generis’) into the Stalinist parties.
It showed what the substitute for a reply had become. The WRP had dropped its plan to republish the post-war documents of the International and issued instead Trotskyism versus Revisionism. That collection begins at the Third World Congress “though without publishing a single one of the main resolutions of that Congress”. “The defence of ‘orthodoxy’ where orthodoxy proves inadequate, has now turned into its opposite, the falsification of history.”
“The Poisoned Well“ followed. It was drafted in November 1977, adopted at the WSL’s second annual conference in February 1978, and printed in Trotskyism Today as a contribution to the United Secretariat’s own discussion for its Eleventh World Congress. It was circulated with an invitation to reply, pressing the International Marxist Group in particular to answer in public. An organisation embracing Pabloism does not write to its alleged co-thinkers asking them to defend themselves. Nor does one that is merely denouncing them. This was an argument, and the WSL followed it into the room: when the Eleventh World Congress met in 1979, the League attended as an observer.
And the WSL changed its mind when the argument required it. In 1975 Problems and Tasks treated the Third World Congress’s admission as the seed of Pablo’s liquidationism: that the bureaucracy had destroyed capitalism in Eastern Europe without the revolutionary action of the masses. In 1978 the League published Tim Wohlforth’s Theory of Structural Assimilation, and Trotskyism Today ran a long study that accepted the 1951 conclusion by another route. Getting a question wrong in public and correcting it in print is what the ICFI’s account of continuity has no room for. The WSL did it in its first three years.
In December 1979 the League hosted the conference that founded the Trotskyist International Liaison Committee, whose Declaration of Intent was endorsed by seven organisations. The ICFI calls this “seeking to regroup various dissidents and splinters from the International Committee”. It was an attempt to do internationally what Problems and Tasks had proposed: rebuild through a discussion of the history, not through a claim to own it.
Inside the Fourth International: against the bureaucracy
The obituary’s next charge is membership. The road in was not a capitulation but a fusion. In 1987 the Socialist Group, the WSL’s successor, merged with the International Group, a minority from the IMG’s successor the Socialist League, to form the International Socialist Group. That ISG “was recognised as a sympathising section of the United Secretariat in 1991 and became its British section in 1995”. In 2008 Marsden called this “his natural political home in the Pabloite USec”. The word does the work. Nothing in either text says what Thornett argued once he was inside.
He argued against the majority, and from exactly the direction the ICFI claims for itself. At the 13th World Congress in 1991 the Tendency for Building the Fourth International put a counter-resolution, “After the Fall of the Berlin Wall“ (International Marxist Review 11/12, 1991). The tendency was formed by the majority of the ISG and a minority of the French Ligue Communiste Révolutionnaire, and it had six of the roughly one hundred delegates. Thornett and the other former Socialist Group comrades in the ISG did a good deal to clarify its politics and to build it. They brought into the International the argument the WSL had been making since 1975. Its quarrel with the majority was over Stalinism.
The majority, the tendency said, had analysed Gorbachev’s policy as an attempt to “de-bureaucratize the bureaucracy”. It had been “relatively indulgent towards glasnost and perestroika”. The tendency’s own position:
in retrospect, our position was closer to the mark, refusing any support for glasnost dictated from above and restorationist perestroika.
It insisted that the alternatives were “capitalist restoration or political revolution”, and that the bureaucracy stood with imperialism against the working class. It called for independence for every oppressed nation of the USSR, against a majority it described as “literally hostile to this policy”. And it greeted the fall of the regimes without the least nostalgia:
The fall of the bureaucratic dictatorships is a positive step for every worker. It was a democratic, revolutionary movement of the people, from below, that toppled the Stalinists. Behind all this was Berlin 1953, Warsaw/Budapest 1956, Prague 1968, and... ten million workers in Solidarnosc in 1980.
There is no socialism possible without democracy, no planning without a considerable expansion of democratic freedoms. This is our programme.
Whatever that is, it is not Pablo. It is the WSL’s 1975 argument against the WRP on Vietnam, carried into the International and put to a vote: do not judge a Stalinist leadership by what it has won. Judge it by what it does to the working class.
He did not drop the argument when the vote went against him. Before the 14th World Congress in 1995, writing as Alan Davies in the ISG’s pre-congress discussion bulletins, he reprinted the 1991 platform of the ISG majority, “Build the Fourth International in Every Country”. It argued that the foundations of a new mass revolutionary international were best laid by organising the maximum forces “on the basis of our international programme - permanent revolution, political revolution, and the revolutionary road to socialism in the advanced countries”. Beside it he reprinted the ISG Political Committee’s 1991 answer to “the sharp turn towards campism” made by the Socialist League, the group around Socialist Action, which had “denounced us as pro-imperialist”. In the Fourth International of the early 1990s, the charge against Thornett’s current from inside was not that it was soft on Stalinism. It was that it was too hard on it.
The same bulletins show whom he was arguing against. An opposition inside the ISG, Tendency A, linked to the International Trotskyist Opposition, had decided that the states of Eastern Europe and the former USSR were already capitalist. It had dropped the call for political revolution. Davies answered with the questions an orthodox Trotskyist asks:
How can you have capitalism without a bourgeoisie? … How can you have capitalism without a market? … How can you have capitalism without capital?
The governments were “completely pro-capitalist”, he granted, but “their intentions alone do not determine the class nature of those states!” To argue otherwise was “to advance either a different theory of the state to that advanced by Lenin, or a seriously mistaken view of what has happened”. And he asked for what this whole article has been asking the ICFI for: “The very least TA could do is to present a proper accounting of how these positions came about”. The opposition’s authors, as I pointed out in the same bulletin under the pen name Lindsey, traced “their continuity back to Healy’s opposition to the principled reunification of the FI in 1963”. In 1995 the defence of Lenin’s theory of the state and the programme of political revolution, inside the British section of the “Pabloite” International, fell to the man the ICFI says had embraced Pabloism.
Honesty requires one more sentence, because a tradition that learns has to mark its own errors. The tendency was wrong about the period. It rejected the majority’s view that the movement had been thrown onto the defensive, and expected “an acceleration of the imperialist crisis” and “immense possibilities” for building the International. The next decade did not bear that out. But being wrong about the period is not the same error as adapting to Stalinism, and it was made from the opposite direction.
The charge with content
There is one place where the WSWS does argue, and it deserves an answer. In March 2008 Marsden took on “Democratic Centralism and Broad Left Parties“, a statement adopted by the Socialist Resistance steering committee in January 2008 from a draft by Phil Hearse. It was written while Socialist Resistance was in Respect Renewal with George Galloway. Marsden read it as Thornett’s own and as a repudiation of Trotskyism: “Thornett rejects entirely Trotsky’s struggle to build the Fourth International”. He quoted its view that “this simplistic ‘build the party’ option is no longer operable” and that the “’thin red line of Bolshevism’ conception of revolutionary politics doesn’t work”. He set it beside Pablo in October 1953. For Pablo, the “least probable” variant was the one in which the masses, disillusioned with the reformists and Stalinists, “break with their traditional mass organisations to come to polarise themselves around our present nuclei”.
The quotations are accurate. What Marsden left out is the paragraph that says what the orientation is not:
What an orientation towards political regroupment of the left does not involve is a fetishisation of a particular political structure, or the idea that broad left parties are the new form of revolutionary party, or the notion that these parties will necessarily last for decades. For us they are interim and transitional forms of organisation … Our goal remains that of building revolutionary parties.
He also quoted “we are not doing entry work or fighting a bureaucratic leadership” without the clause in front of it: “Except in the case of the degeneration of a broad left current (as in Brazil)”. A statement whose stated goal “remains that of building revolutionary parties” cannot be one that “rejects entirely” the struggle to build them. And its diagnosis of the sectarian tradition is one Thornett had been making since 1974. Healy’s SLL-WRP, it says, was “strongly pressurised by third period Stalinism and organisational methods and assumptions inherited from the Stalinised Comintern”. That is the 1974 platform’s objection to calling every Labour and union leader “corporatist”, thirty-four years on.
The comparison with Pablo fails on the point it needs. Pablo’s premise was that the masses would stay inside the Stalinist and reformist parties, and that those parties could be pushed towards revolution. His conclusion was entry into them for the long haul. The broad parties of the 2000s started from the opposite premise. The traditional party had moved so far right that a layer of its supporters was breaking from it, and the question was how revolutionaries should organise alongside them outside it. One can think that wrong. It is not the same mistake.
The statement is open to criticism, but from the opposite direction to the WSWS’s. The ICFI’s own obituary credits the SLL of 1966 with “turning to a substantial leftward movement inside the Labour Party and the trade unions”. It quotes with approval Healy’s slogan “Make the left MPs fight”: a demand on reformist leaders, made to test them in front of their own supporters. In 1974 it was Thornett who defended that campaign, against a WRP that had dropped it. “Trotsky points out in the Transitional Programme that the party has to intervene in the ‘inner struggles’ within reformist organisations,” his first document said. “This was the essence of the ‘Make the Left MPs fight’ campaign waged by the SLL … Today, by failing to adopt this method and tactic developed by Trotsky, we repeatedly let the reformists off the hook.” The obituary praises the slogan and attacks the one man in the 1974 dispute who wanted to keep it. The 2008 statement, though, has no equivalent. Its firmest limit on revolutionaries inside a broad party is “decisive questions of the interest of the working class and oppressed – like sending troops to Afghanistan”. It has nothing on putting the broad party’s own leaders, Galloway included, to a test their supporters could see. Socialist Resistance’s practice inside Respect did better than its statement. Its own later account, “Broad parties and the fight for Left Unity in Britain“, records the demands it kept pressing for Respect to become a democratic membership party, with its own paper, a policy-making conference and a manifesto. It also records what Galloway did with them:
he went on Big Brother in January 2006 “without any consultation within Respect”;
in the 2008 crash he told the National Council that “people are not interested in what we have to say about the crisis”;
in 2010 an election manifesto “commissioned by the National Executive and written by Alan Thornett on the basis of agreed policies was vetoed by an obscure process”.
Respect Renewal declined, the account says, “as George Galloway imposed his own personal control over its structures and functioning”.
The last test came from the least expected direction. On 13 November 2010, a week after Galloway said he was under pressure to stand for the Scottish Parliament, Respect’s conference voted 59 to 15 to organise in Scotland. It reversed what Socialist Resistance called “a long-held policy that Respect does not organise in Scotland”, a change “introduced a week before the conference and with no discussion at the National Council or in the branches”. Socialist Resistance supported the Scottish Socialist Party and the Scottish people’s right to self-determination. It said the decision made its position “untenable“ and left, and many others left with it. It effectively ended the Respect project.
That is the real argument about the last twenty years, and Red Mole would make it. A broad party is not a destination to be reached and then defended. With these parties the journey is the destination. They usually begin by filling an electoral space that social democracy has vacated by moving right. What the people left behind in that old reformist space may not realise is that the old ideas were unsustainable for a reason: reforms granted within capitalism can be clawed back by it, and a party that sets out to manage the system ends up doing the clawing. So the old programme has to be renovated, in at least three ways:
the party has to become anticapitalist;
it has to refuse to take part in governments that attack the working class and its allies;
it has to become ecosocialist and intersectional.
Each of those is a test, and each is one the supporters can see. Along the way some of those who came in from top-down Labourism will take a different path. That is not the project failing; it is part of what the project is. It is why such parties are so often transitional. Trotsky expected exactly this of the British labour movement a century ago. In Where Is Britain Going? he predicted that MacDonald would be “cast out”, but that his likely replacements, “people of the ilk of Lansbury, Wheatley and Kirkwood, will inevitably reveal that they are but a left variant of the same basic Fabian type”. He was right about the first of them: Lansbury led the Labour Party from 1932 to 1935, after MacDonald’s desertion, and the party stayed Fabian under him. The conclusion Trotsky drew is the one that matters here: “The working class will in all probability have to renew its leadership several times before it creates a party really answering the historical situation and the tasks of the British proletariat.”
The question to ask of Respect Renewal is the one we ask of any united front: was there a test the supporters could see, and did those who drew the lesson organise independently afterwards? The 2008 statement left out the first half of that question, and Respect’s history answered it anyway. What Socialist Resistance and the others did after leaving is the second half, and it is the half worth arguing about. That is a criticism worth having. It is not Pabloism, and a label cannot have the argument for us.
The label and the record
The obituary never says what Pabloism is. Its one description of anti-Pabloism is unflattering: the OCI’s 1966 claim that the Fourth International “had been destroyed by Pabloite liquidationism and had to be ‘reconstructed’”, it says, provided “a political mechanism for the party’s adaptation to centrist and Stalinist tendencies”. That is an exact description of what a label can do when it has to stand in for an argument. Thornett is filed under it, and fifty years of documents that would test the filing go unmentioned.
The record runs like this:
1974: a group of car workers was expelled for challenging Healy’s countdown to dictatorship. The ICFI’s own later verdict was that the expulsion was violent and premature, and a political disaster.
1975: within a year they had charged the WRP with going back to Pablo, with quotations, and produced a founding document asking for the political reply the International Committee had never made.
1977–79: they wrote to the United Secretariat inviting an argument, attended its 1979 World Congress as observers, changed their own minds in print, and built an international liaison committee on the principle of rebuilding through discussion.
1991: inside the Fourth International, Thornett and his comrades helped to build a tendency that fought its majority from the anti-Stalinist side.
Meanwhile the organisation that expelled them moved, by the ICFI’s own account, from adaptation to degeneration. Thornett spelled out what that degeneration meant in his 1990 obituary of Healy, the same article the WSWS mines for insults. The WRP sold uncritical coverage to Middle Eastern regimes for money, backed Gaddafi, and supported the Iraqi regime’s execution of Communist Party members, until it blew apart in 1985.
The WSWS promises “a more thorough appraisal”. It should start with Socialist Press of 15 October 1975 and answer it. Fifty-one years is long enough to have found a reply.
Funeral. Alan Thornett’s funeral will be on Tuesday 17 November 2026 at 12 noon at North Oxfordshire Crematorium, Tackley, Kidlington, Oxfordshire OX5 3ER (map). Refreshments afterwards in the Pavilion Function Room at the crematorium.
Getting there. The 10.51am train from Oxford (platform 4) arrives at Tackley at 11am; drivers attending the funeral will run a taxi and shuttle service for the 2.3 miles to the crematorium. Walking from the station, or from the bus stop on the Banbury Road, is not recommended.
Online. The funeral can be watched on Obitus: username sano2772, password 527348.
Tributes, pictures, candles and thoughts can be left at alanthornett.muchloved.com; others are gathered on this site’s tributes page.


